Navigating Antisocial Personality Disorder: Family Therapy

Antisocial personality disorder (ASPD) often poses significant challenges for diagnosed individuals and their family members. ASPD is often associated with instability and may be more likely to arise in families that exhibit specific characteristics, such as abuse, lack of warmth, and financial issues. 

If you or a loved one is experiencing abuse, contact the Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-SAFE (7233). Support is available 24/7.

Due to the nature of ASPD, family therapy may play an important role in managing this condition. A family therapist can help individuals learn essential communication skills designed to navigate the complex family dynamics associated with ASPD. It may also benefit family members of those with ASPD to attend individual therapy to work through any challenges related to their loved one’s personality disorder. Researching ASPD, as well as the therapeutic approaches that address it, may help lessen the impact this condition can have on individuals and families. 

Understanding antisocial personality disorder

Those with ASPD often exhibit a lack of empathy, little regard for societal norms or rules, and a tendency towards manipulative and exploitative behaviors.

ASPD is widely considered to be a complex disorder to treat. Treatment typically depends on the willingness of the person with ASPD to attend therapy, and those with ASPD may not always be open to the idea. However, treating comorbidities such as substance use disorders, anxiety, and mood disorders may be possible. Additionally, conduct disorder (which shares much of the same diagnostic criteria as ASPD but is typically diagnosed in children) is often associated with dysfunctional familial relationships. Because of this, families of those with ASPD may benefit from family therapy.

The role of family therapy in ASPD treatment

ASPD has the potential to impact both the individual and the family system, but family therapy may help lessen this impact by promoting healthy communication, mutual understanding, and healthy boundaries for individuals with ASPD and their families. 

Addressing communication and conflict resolution

Family therapy can provide a structured environment for improving communication and resolving family conflicts. It can teach essential communication skills like active listening and assertiveness, which can effectively help family members express their needs, concerns, and emotions. This improved communication may help reduce instances of misunderstanding, hostility, or power struggles.

Promoting empathy and understanding

Family therapy can help foster empathy and understanding among family members. Individuals with ASPD may develop a greater awareness of the impact of their antisocial behaviors on others, encouraging them to recognize and consider the emotions and needs of their family members. Similarly, family members might gain insight into the underlying factors contributing to ASPD and learn to separate the person from the disorder, which could help facilitate empathy and compassion.

Building healthy boundaries and trust

Family therapy often focuses on establishing and maintaining healthy boundaries within the family system. Therapy may help family members create a structured environment that promotes safety, respect, and accountability by clarifying expectations, defining limits, and reinforcing consequences for inappropriate behavior. Additionally, family therapy typically works towards rebuilding trust within the family unit, as past experiences of manipulation or deceit may pose an added challenge for families.

Providing education and support for family members

Education about the disorder may help family members gain a deeper understanding of the challenges faced by the individual with ASPD. By fostering empathy, family members might be able to lessen the frequency and severity of negative interactions. Therapists can also provide emotional support to family members by acknowledging their experiences, validating their emotions, and offering coping strategies to help navigate the challenges associated with living with someone living with ASPD.

Techniques and approaches in family therapy for ASPD

Family therapy employs various techniques and approaches to help families manage life with ASPD. Some therapeutic methods, like enhanced family treatment (or EFT), may have lower dropout rates than standard family treatment, particularly for high-adversity families. While some types of family therapy may be more effective than others, almost all can help address various challenges that can arise in families of those with personality disorders. 

What type of therapy you choose may depend on the specific situation of you or your loved ones. Some options that may be helpful include:

Cognitive-behavioral family therapy (CBFT)

Cognitive-Behavioral Family Therapy (CBFT) is an evidence-based therapy that combines cognitive and behavioral techniques within family therapy to address a range of family challenges. CBFT aims to help individuals with ASPD and their families identify and modify dysfunctional thoughts and behavior that may contribute to family difficulties. 

CBFT can help families learn communication, problem-solving, and adaptive management strategies. This integrative approach recognizes the reciprocal influence between individual family members. It emphasizes the importance of systemic change in achieving positive outcomes for the individual with ASPD and the family.

Mentalization-based treatment for families (MBT-F)

Mentalization-Based Treatment for Families (MBT-F) is an innovative therapeutic approach specifically designed to address the complex dynamics and challenges faced by families affected by ASPD. 

Building upon the principles of Mentalization-Based Treatment (MBT), MBT-F emphasizes enhancing the family's capacity for mentalization and reflective functioning. Through the guidance of a skilled therapist, MBT-F may help families navigate the interpersonal difficulties associated with ASPD.

Dialectical behavior therapy (DBT) family skills training

DBT Family Skills Training is an extension of Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) that incorporates family members into the therapeutic process to support individuals with emotional dysregulation. It aims to equip family members with essential DBT skills to promote effective communication, emotion regulation, and problem-solving within the family unit. 

Family members may learn mindfulness techniques, distress tolerance skills, interpersonal effectiveness strategies, and emotion regulation techniques through structured group sessions. 

This collaborative approach often helps create a shared understanding of the challenges faced by the individual with ASPD. It fosters a supportive environment that may encourage healthier interactions, reduce conflict, and enhance overall family functioning. 

Structural family therapy

Structural Family Therapy (SFT) addresses ASPD by analyzing and restructuring family dynamics and interactions. 

A structural family therapist can help identify dysfunctional patterns, roles, and hierarchies within the family system. They can help redefine boundaries, establish clearer communication, and improve problem-solving skills. SFT may help promote healthier interaction and enhance family cohesion.

Challenges and considerations in family therapy for ASPD

Therapy for individuals with ASPD presents unique challenges and considerations. Those wishing to attend family therapy with their loved one may want to consider the challenges associated with therapy for ASPD, including:

Resistance and lack of motivation

Individuals with ASPD may resist participating in therapy or lack the intrinsic motivation to change their behaviors. They may not perceive their actions as problematic or see the need for treatment, which can hinder engagement in the therapeutic process.

Manipulative and deceptive behaviors

Individuals with ASPD are often known for their manipulative and deceptive behaviors. They may attempt to manipulate the therapist or other family members during therapy sessions, disrupting the therapeutic process and hindering progress.

Safety concerns

ASPD is often associated with impulsive and aggressive behaviors. Safety considerations are crucial in family therapy, as there may be a risk of harm to family members during sessions. Therapists should have strategies in place to ensure the physical and emotional safety of all participants.

Balancing individual and family needs

Family therapy addresses the needs of the individual with ASPD and their family members. However, it is essential to strike a balance between addressing the specific challenges and behaviors associated with ASPD while also considering the emotional well-being and needs of family members affected by the disorder.

Addressing co-occurring disorders

ASPD often co-occurs with other mental health conditions, such as substance use disorder, conduct disorders, or mood disorders. These co-occurring disorders can complicate the therapeutic process and require a comprehensive and integrated approach to address multiple challenges.

Ethical considerations

Therapists working with individuals with ASPD face ethical dilemmas related to managing the risk of harm to others, maintaining secrecy, and balancing the needs of the individual with ASPD and other therapy participants. These ethical considerations can pose additional challenges and require careful navigation in family therapy.

Despite these challenges, family therapy may hold significant potential for supporting individuals with ASPD and their families. Treatment has the ability to provide valuable communication skills and create a more cohesive and resilient family unit. It may also be helpful for family members to seek treatment if they believe their mental health is affected by their loved one’s ASPD.

Effectiveness of individual and family therapy for ASPD

While the evidence for psychological interventions for ASPD may be limited, treatment for ASPD could involve a combination of talk therapy and medications. However, like many Cluster-B personality disorders, therapy success for those with ASPD may vary widely between individuals. Part of this varied success is due to the nature of ASPD itself, as individuals experiencing ASPD may find it challenging to understand why treatment is needed. Thus, family therapy may be a valuable aspect of ASPD management in addition to individual therapy for the affected individual. 

Due to the nature of ASPD, a solid familial support network may help individuals with ASPD better manage their condition; in fact, research has found that patients who show remission had better social support and were more likely to have spousal or family ties.

Additionally, ASPD has been found to occur in those whose family members exhibit certain maladaptive traits, such as a negative attitude towards the individual with ASPD, poorer mental health functioning, and lower levels of problem-solving skills.

Because of this, it may also be worthwhile for family members to attend individual therapy in addition to family therapy. A mental health professional may be able to help family members learn how to manage their mental health alongside their relationship with the individual with ASPD. 

Finding a therapist

You may find a family therapist through an online search for family therapists in your area. Most family counselors are licensed family and marriage therapists (LMFT) trained to help families confront challenges that often accompany personality disorders like ASPD.

Many online therapy platforms do not offer family therapy; however, family members may consider connecting with an individual therapist to help them improve their mental health. In-person or online therapy may be a valuable source of understanding and can teach coping skills for better managing challenging family dynamics. Many people find speaking with a therapist from their own home is a more comfortable experience than going to an office.

Online therapy has been shown to be just as or more effective than in-person therapy while often being more convenient and affordable. Some virtual therapy platforms also provide additional services that may be helpful, including messaging, journaling, group therapy, and webinars.