What Is Noam Chomsky’s Influence On Psychology?
Despite being a renowned linguist, Noam Chomsky has contributed significantly to the field of psychology. His contributions are typically associated with the creation of the theory of generative grammar, which is considered to be a significant addition to the field of theoretical linguistics in the 20th century.
Below, we’ll discuss Chomsky’s linguistic theories and their impact on the field of psychology.
Noam Chomsky: The linguist
Noam Chomsky is not a psychologist, nor did he originally plan on psychology being part of his research. As a linguist, he became famous for investigating various kinds of formal languages and whether it was possible to capture key properties of human language.
It was his theories about how children develop language, however, that would have a profound effect on the field of psychology. While it remains a mystery exactly how children segment syllables and words out of the sounds that they hear and acquire grammar to understand and produce language, different theories came into existence in the 1950s. These theories formed the basis for a field focused on how language development occurs.
One of the main theories was part of the work of Burrhus Frederic Skinner, otherwise known as B.F. Skinner. He was part of a group of behaviorists whose work centered on proposing new forms of learning. Skinner believed that classical conditioning was a far too simplistic explanation of what was complex human behavior. Part of his work included using positive and negative reinforcement to achieve desired results. In the context of language, Skinner put forth the idea that language development occurs through environmental influence.
Essentially, he argued that children learn language through behavioral reinforcement, whereby they realize the communicative value of words and phrases as correct utterances are positively reinforced.
Noam Chomsky thought that this theory left out several key components. He argued that children would never acquire the tools needed for processing an infinite number of sentences if the language acquisition mechanism were completely dependent on language input.
This system is thought to contain all the grammatical information needed to combine nouns and verbs into phrases. Thus, Chomsky believed that a child merely needs to learn the words of their language, as grammar is already hardwired into their brains.
Generative grammar
At its heart, Chomsky’s theory of generative grammar was a way of describing how people learn to communicate. The idea was that in order for us to build our levels of knowledge, some basic knowledge must already be present.
Chomsky argued that there is a distinction between the deep structure of language and the surface structure of language. Therefore, he put forth the idea that the deep structure aspects, including the meaning of a sentence, are not cultural but rather hardwired into the brain. That meaning is then transformed into the surface structure of words and sounds.
Chomsky hypothesized that the Language Acquisition Device (LAD) explained the acquisition of the syntactic structure of language because it was the system that determined the features of a child's native language or mother tongue. While it was a naturalistic approach, the theory gained support among experts in the field of language and behavior.
In a twist of the networking concepts of Information Processing Theory, Chomsky posited that knowledge, specifically procedural knowledge, becomes irreducible in complexity. When something is successfully networked, it can become intrinsically tied to its immediate network in a learner's mind. As a result, Chomsky believes that language is a purely cognitive phenomenon, and as opposed to behavioral.
He believed that language is not a product of cultural trial and error but is a reconstruction of instinctive knowledge that we already have. He also believed that each language spoken today has a common root in the language center of our brains. The different attributes of languages are then associated with various opportunities and approaches to networking verbiage and syntax.
The impact of generative grammar theory
Over the years, various linguists have modified the theoretical principles and methods related to transformational generative grammar. One of the points of this theory is to explain a native speaker's linguistic competence by framing linguistic descriptions regarding rules for creating an infinite number of grammatical sentences.
Within American psychology, Chomsky's theory paved the way for the cognitive revolution as a shift from behaviorism. Additionally, in his 1966 book, Cartesian Linguistics, and subsequent works, he laid out an explanation of human language faculties, which has become a model for investigation in various areas of psychology.
Three key ideas from Chomsky
There are three key ideas that came from Chomsky's theory that have impacted the present concept of how the mind works. The first of these ideas is that the mind is cognitive, which means that it contains mental states, beliefs, doubts, and more.
Secondly, Chomsky argued that the most important properties of language and mind are innate within us. Therefore, the development of our language abilities is based on the unfolding of innate propensities provoked by input from our environment and culture. This idea has now been extended beyond language, creating a move away from traditional behavior theories.
Finally, Chomsky developed the concept of "modularity," a critical feature of how the cognitive mind is defined. The mind, he argued, is composed of an array of interacting, specialized subsystems, but with limited flows of inter-communication.
Stages of generative grammar
There are various stages that have been developed since Chomsky first introduced the idea of generative grammar and cognitive theory. As a result, there is increasing systematic insight into the structure of human language capacity as a component of cognitive endowment.
The first stage proposed a system of levels that systematically characterize linguistic expressions by their formal properties. This system created a complex theory of mental organization, which contrasted with the orientation of behaviorists in psychology.
The second stage was the Standard Theory, which described grammatical transformations related to levels of the syntactic organization, the deep structure, and the surface structure. Each of them had a part in determining the semantic and phonetic interpretation for those transformations.
As more generalizations occurred, the third stage developed, which is known as the Principles-and-Parameters Theory. This iteration of the theory showed that most of the language properties accounted for by idiosyncratic syntactic rules are derivable from general principles. With this change, individual languages seem to differ only with respect to lexical information and a restricted set of parameters that universal principles are sensitive to.
The impact of Chomsky
Chomsky’s theories have been distilled, which has further reduced language-specific principles to general conditions of cognitive organization. Chomsky's theory opened the door to cognitive sciences, moving the field of psychology in a new direction. Research into language development, including the biology of language, computational linguistics, neurolinguistics, and language acquisition, has only grown and has influenced formal semantics and pragmatics and the philosophy of language in general.
These contributions have allowed the field of psychology to grow in a new direction and have brought to light the need to understand and research how the mind works, not only regarding language but also in other areas as well.
Chomsky has been active in politics and has been influential as a philosopher, scientist, and professor. Throughout his life, he has maintained that the goal of teaching is to help cultivate the growth and interest of children in exploring and learning. These ideas have lasted into the present day and continue to have an impact in numerous fields.
Where does this leave language acquisition?
While Chomsky and his theories have influenced the cognitive aspects of psychology, there is still no definitive answer to the problem of language acquisition. Some of the questions that researchers are still trying to answer include:
- What is the exact process that transforms a child's utterances into grammatically correct, adult-like speech?
- How much does a child need to be exposed to language to achieve an adult-like communication state?
- What accounts for the variation between languages and the language acquisition process for children who are not raised to speak English as their first language?
Chomsky’s theory posited that our environment has an impact but that nature plays a larger part than might have originally been thought in the early part of the 20th century. At its heart, Chomsky's work seeks to understand and describe how people learn to communicate.
Additionally, his work has pointed to the idea that all human language originates from a common source, an innate set of grammatical rules and approaches that is hardwired into the human mind.
Online counseling with BetterHelp
If you have questions about language development, psychology, or mental health, you might consider speaking with a licensed psychologist or therapist. If you don’t have time to see a therapist in person, you might consider online therapy. With an online therapy service like BetterHelp, you can be matched with a therapist who has knowledge of language development or whatever specific areas of concern you’re facing.
With BetterHelp, you can connect with a licensed therapist from home via phone, live chat, or videoconferencing. You can also contact your therapist at any time through in-app messaging, and they’ll get back to you as soon as they can.
The efficacy of online therapy
Online therapy has been shown to be effective for a variety of mental health conditions. One study found that internet-based cognitive behavioral therapy (ICBT) interventions successfully managed and treated conditions like depression, generalized anxiety disorder (GAD), panic disorder, obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), bipolar disorder, and phobias. CBT is a therapeutic approach that aims to teach people how to identify their negative, inaccurate thoughts and replace them with more helpful ones.
If you are experiencing trauma, support is available. Please see our Get Help Now page for more resources.
Takeaway
Science is continually evolving, and this includes the mental health field. To understand more about your own mental health, you might consider connecting with an online therapist. BetterHelp has a network of more than 25,000 psychologists and therapists, so you can be matched with someone who has experience in your specific areas of concern. Take the first step toward getting help and reach out to BetterHelp today.
What was Noam Chomsky known for in psychology?
While he made several noteworthy contributions to the field of psychology, one of the best-known Noam Chomsky psychology theories was the psycholinguistic theory of language acquisition. In this theory, Chomsky posits that our brains have what's known as a language acquisition device or LAD, a form of innate mental processing that allows humans to acquire languages. Chomsky opposed the behaviorist theory that all language is learned through this theory, claiming that structures that interpret and produce speech are naturally built into the cognitive framework of our minds.
Despite the controversial nature of some of his theories, Chomsky has received a number of awards, including the 1984 Award for Distinguished Scientific Contribution, presented by the American Psychological Association. In addition to his commendations from the APA, Chomsky has been given a Benjamin Franklin Medal in Computer and Cognitive Science, a Sydney Peace Prize, and an award from the Nuclear Age Peace Foundation.
Was Chomsky a psycholinguist?
Avram Noam Chomsky has worked extensively in the field of linguistics and psycholinguistics and is credited with contributions like generative grammar, the Chomsky hierarchy, and universal grammar. He has also worked in multiple other fields, including philosophy, psychology, cognitive science, mathematics, childhood education, and anthropology.
In addition to his writing, Chomsky is noteworthy for the early age at which he began his collegiate studies (Chomsky attended the University of Pennsylvania at the early age of 16). Today, Chomsky is a political activist and currently works as a laureate professor of linguistics at the University of Arizona. He also holds the title of Professor of Linguistics Emeritus at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT).
What approach did Chomsky use?
Chomsky’s approach to linguistics, which involved the concept of universal grammar, is defined by his theory of language acquisition. This theory posits that language acquisition is a biologically determined process involving the language acquisition device or LAD. Chomsky believed that all humans have this device within their brains at birth and that it can allow them to learn any language. He also argued that we understand language by unconsciously storing information relating to verbal and written communication. As such, Chomsky believed that language had less to do with individual learning and more to do with innate parts of the human mind.
What was Chomsky's point of view about psycholinguistics?
Noam Chomsky argued that linguistics and the ability to learn languages could both shed light on important aspects of cognitive psychology. He also suggested that all humans are born with structures within their brains designed to contain the structure for languages. This concept, known as universal grammar, posits that humans have an innate grasp of language due to the possession of the language acquisition device or LAD. Chomsky believed that learning took place through this mechanism and was influenced by one’s environment.
What are Chomsky's main theories?
One of Noam Chomsky’s main theories was his theory of language acquisition, which argued that the rules and structures for humans to learn and use language are innate, inborn features of the brain. According to Chomsky, the primary biological feature that facilitates this process is what's known as the language acquisition device (LAD), which enables children to have the capacity to learn and use any language. In order for the LAD to do this, it uses unconsciously gathered information-related language, including that which is read or heard by a child.
What is the relationship between linguistics and psychology?
While linguistics and psychology are closely related fields of study, they do have their own distinct definitions and goals. Linguistics is the study of language, while psychology specifically focuses on the study of human (and non-human) minds and behavior.
However, these two fields do connect in a separate area of study, one that focuses entirely on the relationships between psychological processes and linguistic behavior: psycholinguistics. Psycholinguistics seeks to analyze and describe the processes that allow us to develop, comprehend, produce, and master speech and language.
What are the limitations of Chomsky's theory?
One limitation to Chomsky’s theory of language acquisition is that the majority of his psycholinguistic work was theoretical. This lack of empirical scientific evidence could strengthen criticism of his theories. In addition, Chomsky’s theory did not account for people with disabilities or those who experience delays in language learning and development. These factors may affect how a person acquires languages, but his theory doesn’t address these possibilities. As such, there have been critics to a number of Chomsky language theories, particularly renowned psychologist B.F. Skinner.
How did Chomsky prove his theory?
While Chomsky did not necessarily prove his theories through experimentation, he did present evidence to back up his main arguments. One piece of evidence he used relates to the errors children make through speech, which often include grammatical mistakes that one wouldn’t hear from an adult. Referred to as the Poverty of Stimulus argument, Chomsky posits that these errors were evidence of an inborn grasp of grammatical structure, even if that grasp was flawed. Chomsky also cited the similarities between languages across the world, which made up the basis for what he called “universal grammar,” an innate linguistic component of language that all humans are born with.
Why is it so difficult to learn a new language in adulthood?
Part of the reason that learning a new language as an adult can be challenging is due to the way our brain develops throughout early childhood and adolescence. Because areas of the brain like the prefrontal cortex are still rapidly developing at a young age, children are often able to make neural connections at a faster pace. As we age and our brain develops fully, it may be more difficult to form new neural pathways. While adults may have a better grasp of explicit or conscious memory, children can have better implicit memory; these implicit systems can allow someone to learn unconsciously and may not require the same intentional recall as explicit memories.
Who disagreed with Chomsky's theory?
One famous piece of Noam Chomsky criticism comes from B.F. Skinner, a psychologist known for his extensive work in the field of behaviorism. Chomsky and Skinner’s views on linguistics and verbal behavior conflicted significantly. Skinner believed that language was learned through social influences and reinforcement. For example, a child may learn the word “dog” and point to their family dog. As a result, their parents could reinforce this and other behaviors by giving them positive affirmations or a physical reward. This opposes Chomsky’s view, which suggests that language is innate and inborn.
- Previous Article
- Next Article