Psychoanalysis Therapy: Psychology & Mental Health Benefits
Also known as psychodynamic therapy, psychoanalytic therapy is a type of therapy that focuses on the dialogue between the therapist and client to support the expression of repressed emotions that may date back to childhood. This type of counseling, such as psychodynamic therapy online, is often used to treat mental health conditions like anxiety and depression.
The psychoanalytic therapy approach explores the underlying causes behind mental health difficulties to help identify and strategize healthy ways of moving forward and regaining a solid sense of self.
The history of psychoanalytic therapy in psychology
The history of psychodynamic psychotherapy is rooted in the subject of psychoanalysis. The origins of psychoanalytic therapy were developed by Sigmund Freud in the late 1890s when he worked in a children's hospital. He noticed that many children had symptoms of poor mental health with no apparent cause and that some mental processes were subconscious. These thoughts were considered to be unconscious thoughts from the unconscious mind.
Freud later received a grant to work with Jean-Martin Charcot, a pioneer in the nascent field of psychology. Charcot had developed a hypnotism technique to help patients experiencing hysteria, which was conventionally considered to be one of several psychological disorders.
Freud's role in psychoanalysis therapy
Freud continued to study hypnosis and went on to work with a colleague named Josef Breuer. Breuer and Freud collaborated on a book called "Studies on Hysteria," which brought to light specific therapeutic techniques used in hypnosis.
Freud developed talk therapy as an alternative to hypnosis and began working with psychoanalytic techniques. He proposed the psychoanalytic theory that talking about problems could be a mental health treatment that significantly relieves the anguish of individuals experiencing emotional distress. Freud believed that the therapist-patient relationship would build dialogue to help clients heal from suppressed emotions.
Current views on Freud’s theories regarding psychoanalytic therapy
Many of Sigmund Freud's theories are considered outdated by modern practitioners of clinical psychology in the United States and worldwide. However, the ideas and theories behind traditional psychoanalysis have been profoundly impactful in the field. The psychoanalytic theory that Freud founded, followed by Anna Freud, was one of the bases of modern therapy, and many types of therapy stemmed from it.
How does psychoanalytic therapy work?
Psychoanalytic therapists might attempt to talk through repressed memories and locate their origin. The psychoanalytic theory revolves around the idea that many emotional responses are due to the unconscious mind and may need to be brought into conscious awareness. Patients may experience several types of mental health problems that can be helped through this therapeutic process of psychoanalysis. Sigmund Freud believed treatment and healing would most likely occur once patients consciously understood their feelings and thoughts. In some cases, psychoanalytic therapy may utilize features of attachment theory to understand how adverse childhood experiences may impact an individual as an adult.
Active listening and note-taking are two techniques that psychoanalytic therapists might utilize. During their psychoanalytic therapy sessions, the patient may spend time talking about their concerns, childhood, interpersonal relationships, and any events that could have led to their current emotional state. The therapist might then try to find self-destructive patterns and maladaptive thinking. For example, repetitive behaviors and thoughts that may show a patient are "stuck" in a particular mode of thought or situation might be highlighted and treated. This type of therapeutic relationship can help patients who experience both somatic symptoms and symptoms of psychological distress, such as depressive symptoms.
“Talking cure” in psychoanalysis therapy
Part of psychoanalytic therapy's purported strength is that patients often work through their mental turmoil and adverse experiences by speaking about them. Freud referred to this as the "talking cure." Psychoanalysis, similar to behavior therapy, aims to improve the mental health of the patient and lessen the psychological symptoms. How is behavior therapy different than psychoanalysis? Psychoanalytic therapy targets to understand the unconscious mind of the patient while behavior therapy focuses on the action-oriented approach to improve outcomes.
Psychoanalytic therapy research from the American Psychoanalytic Association & more
Multiple peer-reviewed clinical psychology studies have shown the effectiveness of psychoanalytic therapy. For example, World Psychiatry conducted a meta-analysis from high-quality sources on the results of psychoanalytic therapy. In many cases, psychoanalytic therapy was more effective than other therapies in treating depressive symptoms.
Another article published by American Psychologist conducted a meta-analysis on this topic. It concluded that psychoanalytic therapy often significantly reduced depressive symptoms and symptoms related to personality and mood disorders.
More research from the American Psychoanalytic Association & Vienna Psychoanalytic Society
The latest evidence-based research, reviewed and conducted by medical reviewers and board-certified physicians, continues to boast the effectiveness of psychoanalytic therapy for various conditions. You can find more information about the latest evidence-based research on psychoanalytic therapy from the American Psychoanalytic Association. For additional content, psychoanalytic societies like the Vienna Psychoanalytic Society (formerly the Wednesday Psychological Society) offer up-to-date research and news.
What are the benefits of psychoanalytic therapy? Addressing stress, anxiety, and more
The primary goal of psychodynamic psychotherapy is often to significantly reduce the symptoms of various mental health conditions or emotional distress. Many studies have concluded that psychodynamic therapy can be effective for those living with depressive symptoms. However, people experiencing anxiety, panic disorder, personality disorders, eating disorders, somatic symptoms, or other stress-related conditions may also benefit.
What if you don’t have mental health concerns like anxiety or stress?
Even if you do not live with these conditions but experience issues with your current behavior or psychological distress, you may be able to find treatment and support through psychodynamic psychotherapy. Many emotional responses and self-destructive behaviors could be revealed through challenges in interpersonal relationships and daily life stressors.
Seeking referrals for psychology treatment and mental health disorders
Before choosing a form of therapy, seek professional medical advice or referral. Talk with a qualified therapist about your symptoms and concerns to receive guidance and support. There may be another type of treatment than psychoanalytic therapy that your therapist feels would better suit your needs, so discussing your goals beforehand can be valuable.
Psychoanalytic techniques and psychoanalysis concepts: Free association, transference, and more
Below are a few psychoanalytic techniques and concepts used in this form of therapy.
Free association and dream interpretation in psychology
One technique used in psychoanalytic therapy involves wordplay. The free association technique developed by Freud involves a client speaking the first thought that comes to mind when a therapist offers them a word or phrase. In psychoanalytic therapy, the therapist may employ free association and then interpret why the associations were made or what unconscious thoughts or feelings the client may have.
Dream analysis, or dream interpretation, could also be utilized. Dream analysis can involve a client recounting a dream or dreams that they have had, including recurring, vivid, or distressing dreams. The psychoanalyst might consider the cause of these dreams based on the subconscious theory. For example, there may be repressed memories or subconscious urges expressed.
Psychoanalytic therapy often considers dreams to be powerful manifestations of our subconscious mind. For example, you might not be fully aware that you are harboring resentment towards an individual but have a dream where you are yelling or angry at this person. When awake, you may discuss the dream with your therapist and learn more about where these emotions might have stemmed from.
Examining dreams through the lens of psychology
In psychoanalytic therapy, your analyst may help you understand the forces behind dreams that may seem confusing or disturbing. The therapist could try to find repetitive themes and objects that might be symbolic. For instance, you might repeatedly dream of flying away from your home. Your therapist may interpret this as an urge to detach, move, or avoid conflict. Not all psychologists use dream interpretation, but reaching out to a psychoanalytic provider can help you learn more about available resources. One may opt for object relations therapy since it is a variation of Sigmund Freud's psychoanalytic theory, which influences psychoanalytic therapy
Transference in psychoanalytic therapy
In psychoanalytic therapy, patients often discuss individuals who hurt or otherwise profoundly affected them. This discussion can provide the therapist an entryway to discuss the idea of "transference." In psychoanalytic therapy, transference is a negative occurrence that involves taking feelings about one person and redirecting them to another. For instance, someone may have issues with a parent and transfer these feelings onto their significant other through arguments.
Therapists offering transference analysis therapy might work with patients to break down transference to understand why it occurs and how to reduce this habit. Therapists may use transference analysis to improve maladaptive behaviors or cognitive distortions.
Overcoming defense mechanisms
During this therapy, your therapist may help you discover and overcome defense mechanisms. Defense mechanisms often occur as a defensive measure that shields a person from the stress of facing internal and external stressors. Once you are aware of maladaptive behaviors, you may be able to react constructively to challenging scenarios.
Should I try free association, transference, or other psychoanalytic therapy techniques?
Psychoanalytic therapy may not work for everyone. It can involve probing into the unconscious mind and suppressed emotions, which may be vulnerable and scary for many. However, these interventions can be therapeutic, so if you believe they may benefit you, consider searching for a psychoanalytic therapist in your area or online.
How to find a psychoanalytic therapist for mental health
Psychoanalytic therapists may have specific training in psychoanalytic therapy, including knowledge of the latest theories and methods. They might also have experience practicing psychoanalytic therapy. Look for a therapist with an up-to-date license to practice in your state. You can learn more about what makes a qualified psychoanalyst by reviewing information from the American Psychoanalytic Association.
When searching for a therapist, try to find someone you connect with and trust. Therapy can be a vulnerable process, so it may be difficult to talk to a therapist you do not trust. You might try multiple psychotherapists before finding one you feel comfortable with. Over time, delving into deeper topics may become easier as you strengthen your therapist-patient relationship.
Psychoanalytic therapy and counseling options to improve mental health
Therapy can be a personal experience, and each person may seek different results. If you think psychoanalytic theory aligns with your goals for therapy, this treatment method could help you uncover your unconscious thoughts and memories that may influence how you manage daily life. You can try this form of therapy in person or online.
Online psychoanalysis therapy for mental health disorders
Online therapy can allow you the convenience of attending therapy from home or any location with an internet connection, which might be beneficial if you struggle to open up with a therapist in person. If you're interested in trying this counseling method, consider signing up for a platform like BetterHelp, which offers a growing database of experienced counselors licensed to practice various forms of therapy, including psychoanalysis and other popular forms of treatment like cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT).
What does the research say about online mental health treatment?
Online psychodynamic therapy has been studied to measure its efficacy compared to in-person therapy. For example, in a study published in the Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association, psychotherapists reported that, despite the technical and relational challenges of remote sessions, they felt as emotionally connected to their clients as they did in traditional in-person sessions.
Takeaway
Your mental health can matter as much as your physical well-being. Many types of counseling are available for treating stress, mental health symptoms, and psychological conditions. If you're looking to start psychoanalytic therapy or another form of counseling, consider reaching out to a mental health professional for further information and guidance.
What disorders does psychoanalytic therapy treat?
Psychoanalytic psychotherapy is one of the oldest approaches to therapy. It is based on the work of Sigmund Freud, the inventor of psychoanalysis's original theories. The psychoanalysis theory of Freud includes concepts such as the Oedipus complex, reality testing (the ego realizes the differences between the internal and external world), dream analysis, and more. Psychoanalysis began in the 19th century, but it was expanded and updated over decades by well-known psychological researchers like Carl Jung, Otto Rank, and Alfred Adler. Associated theories of psychoanalytic therapy include drive theory, object relations theory, ego psychology, self psychology, interpersonal psychoanalysis, psychodynamic theory, and more. Defining psychoanalytic therapy today is challenging. Psychoanalytic therapy has become an umbrella term representing many different theoretical approaches to therapy, making identifying a unifying definition difficult.
Today’s psychoanalytic psychotherapy is different from Freud’s original psychoanalysis but retains some general themes. Psychoanalytic therapy typically focuses on understanding the human mind and behavior by exploring unconscious thoughts and feelings that may relate to underlying emotional conflicts. Psychoanalytic therapists or psychoanalysts interpret the conflict between conscious and unconscious thoughts and help patients navigate defense mechanisms that obstruct emotional awareness and the patient’s sense of self. While the psychoanalysis of Sigmund Freud is not considered a viable practice in its original form, today’s version of psychoanalytic therapy has a strong evidence base supporting its use.
Psychoanalytic treatment can be effective for various mental health conditions, such as depressive symptoms, anxiety disorders, psychosomatic disorders, obsessive-compulsive disorders, and sexual challenges. Further, a therapist may also use psychoanalysis therapy as a treatment approach for patients experiencing self-destructive behavior and self-esteem challenges. A psychoanalysis therapist may use techniques such as free association, transference analysis, dream analysis, or interpretation to know the unconscious conflicts or repressed thoughts and how they affect a person's psychological aspects.
What are the four basic components of psychoanalysis therapy?
Four aspects form the essence of psychoanalytic techniques: interpretation, transference analysis, countertransference analysis, and technical neutrality.
Interpretation. Interpretation is the blanket term for the verbal interactions between patient and therapist.
Analysis of transference. Transference refers to the unconscious repetition of past conflicts in the present and is commonly analyzed to find the primary target of change the patient desires.
Analysis of countertransference. Countertransference refers to the therapist’s emotional reaction to the patient and what they describe. Psychoanalytic therapists must understand their countertransference to provide high-quality psychoanalytic treatment.
Technical neutrality. Technical neutrality means that the therapist does not benefit from the therapeutic relationship and presents a sincere approach to therapy.
What are the steps in psychoanalytic therapy?
The structure of psychoanalytic therapy sessions for mental health treatment can vary based on the patient's needs, mental illness, and the therapist's discretion. However, to help a person understand the connection between past experiences and present behavior and feelings, psychoanalytic therapy treatment often follows four distinct stages:
Intellectual awareness. The first few months of psychoanalysis therapy treatment are often dedicated to helping the patient gain an intellectual understanding of their issues. In ego psychology, architected by Sigmund and Anna Freud, the ego mediates the id (sense of self) and super-ego. When the ego cannot effectively balance the id and super-ego, feelings of anxiety and guilt can occur. Knowing the ego psychology of a person can help in understanding the connection between repressed thoughts and their current behavior or issues.
Emotional awareness. In psychoanalytic therapy treatment, the therapist helps the patient understand their feelings, remove unconscious blocks to emotional expression, and process their emotions within their conscious mind.
Reconstruction. After thorough analysis, the therapist helps the patient rebuild their self-concept and develop confidence in themselves during the treatment process.
Mastery. Part of psychoanalytic therapy treatment is mastery. The patient practices their skills and masters the ability to manage the circumstances that brought them to psychoanalytic therapy.
What is the difference between psychodynamic and psychoanalytic therapy?
There is very little difference between psychoanalytic therapy and psychodynamic psychotherapy. The American Psychoanalytic Association uses the term “psychodynamic psychotherapy” interchangeably with “psychoanalytic therapy,” and today, there is very little distinction between the two. Many experts choose to use psychodynamic psychotherapy to avoid confusion with psychoanalysis, the original psychoanalytic technique developed by Sigmund Freud. Psychoanalysis of Sigmund Freud is not the same as psychodynamic therapy or psychoanalytic therapy, although the foundational principles of psychoanalysis theory can still be found within modern forms of the technique.
Why is psychoanalytic therapy not used as often anymore?
Psychoanalytic therapy is partially based on psychoanalysis, one of the oldest forms of therapy, first invented by Sigmund Freud in the late 19th century. Carl Jung, Alfred Adler, Otto Rank, and other researchers have expanded psychoanalysis. Since that time, the psychoanalytic therapy of Sigmund Freud has grown and evolved. Its modern iteration-commonly referred to as psychodynamic therapy-incorporates many techniques that were not present in Freud’s original psychoanalytical conception. However, many current psychodynamic methods have been superseded by techniques of other therapies that are generally considered more effective.
Cognitive therapy and cognitive-behavioral therapy rose to prominence in the mid-20th century, and cognitive-behavioral therapy, in particular, has typically been considered the gold standard in modern psychotherapy. Many therapists prefer to use the most modern and well-evidenced treatment techniques available for patients with concerns about mental health and relationships. Psychoanalytic therapy, in many cases, is seen as an outdated and inefficient way to address mental health concerns. However, research continues into psychodynamic techniques, integrating psychoanalytic principles with modern approaches, as seen in methods like short-term psychodynamic therapy.
How is psychoanalytic therapy different from other types of therapy?
Psychoanalytic therapy and other therapies are tools that help patients handle issues in mental health and relationships. The approach used by a therapist in psychoanalytic therapy is different from other therapies.
Some of the most effective and widespread modern therapy techniques work by investigating and modifying the relationship between thoughts, feelings, and behaviors. Other effective techniques focus on evaluating the present moment without eliciting an emotional response or accepting things one cannot change. While some modern techniques of other therapies focus on development through the lifespan, psychoanalytic therapy, in particular, relies on analyzing past life events and childhood experiences of a person to explain emotional or psychological concerns through the use of psychoanalytic technique/s. Through analyzing and interpreting conscious factors of the mind, unconscious emotional barriers can be effectively removed, reducing the psychological symptoms that patients experience.
In treating a person with depressive symptoms, for example, other therapies may help in identifying and reframing unhelpful thoughts and behavior to improve emotional regulation and alleviate the symptoms. However, psychoanalysts follow different directions. Treatment for depression involves allowing the person to delve into past experiences and bring hidden conflicts to consciousness (conscious mind) through free association or other techniques. In some cases, a therapist may use attachment theory. Working collaboratively with the therapist, the person with depression will be able to deal with and resolve the conflicts that influence thoughts and feelings.
What is the basic aim of psychoanalytic therapy?
As with all types of psychotherapy, psychoanalysts or therapists of psychoanalytic therapy aim to relieve adverse feelings or behaviors associated with emotional or psychological factors. Psychoanalytic therapy is based on Freud’s work and the theories of psychoanalysis. Psychoanalytic therapy seeks to help patients achieve meaningful change by analyzing their self-concepts relating to past life experiences. The therapist utilizes in-depth talk therapy and psychoanalytic technique/s, such as dream analysis and free association, to bring repressed emotions to the conscious mind and understand the association between past experiences and present feelings and behavior. The analysis process utilized by psychoanalysts allows the patients to gain insight into the factors related to their concerns and take meaningful steps to rebuild their self-perception.
Finding the right psychoanalytic therapist:
The right therapist is crucial for the treatment process. Check the credentials and expertise of your therapist. A psychoanalytic therapist has master's level training in social work and may also have doctoral-level training in the field of psychology. Psychoanalytic therapy, just like other therapies, is a non-judgemental therapeutic approach that helps a person understand and improve their mental health condition. The psychoanalytic therapist helps a person bring unconscious conflicts to consciousness (conscious mind) in a nonjudgemental way. However, it is worth mentioning that having the right therapist is not enough. Successful therapy requires collaborative work between the therapist and the patient.
What disorders are best treated with psychoanalytic therapy?
The American Psychoanalytic Association indicates that psychoanalytic therapy can be an effective treatment, or a component of effective treatment, for a wide range of emotional and psychological difficulties. The psychoanalytic therapy approach for mental health treatment may be different from other therapies, but it is best for patients whose concerns can be addressed through self-exploration, analysis, and self-perception reconstruction.
Evidence suggests that psychoanalytic therapy, or psychodynamic treatment, may effectively treat depression, anxiety, PTSD, and other stress-related concerns. The evidence further suggests that this treatment approach helps address chronic pain and other physical problems related to healthcare. Finally, there is a small amount of literature that suggests psychoanalytic therapy can effectively treat personality disorders and eating disorders. Further research may be needed in this aspect. Those seeking psychoanalytic therapists or psychoanalysts may want to consider whether their concerns align with the fundamental psychoanalytic process.
Which is better, CBT or psychoanalysis?
Cognitive behavioral therapy and psychoanalysis therapy are both helpful forms of treatment for mental health conditions. Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) identifies and changes maladaptive thoughts that contribute to mental illness. In contrast, psychoanalysis therapy focuses on examining the unconscious conflicts from past experiences of the patients to identify the underlying reason for the mental illness. Sigmund Freud formulated the psychoanalysis theory in the 19th century. Freud believes that thoughts and feelings repressed in the unconscious state can cause anxiety or physical symptoms. This theory of Freud became the foundation of psychoanalytic therapy.
Cognitive behavioral therapy and psychoanalysis therapy have advantages and disadvantages. If you're choosing between these two treatment options for depression or other mental health conditions, preferences, therapeutic goals, and severity of the symptoms should be considered. Whether you opt for cognitive behavioral therapy, psychoanalytic therapy, or other therapies, discuss your treatment options with your therapist or health care provider.
What happens in a psychoanalysis therapy session?
Psychoanalytic therapy believes that unconscious conflicts from past experiences can affect present relationship patterns and behavior. This is a type of talk therapy based on the principles of psychoanalytic theory by Sigmund Freud. According to Sigmund Freud, a person will be able to deal with internal conflicts when unconscious thoughts or feelings are brought to consciousness. If not, these repressed thoughts and feelings may cause depression, anxiety, or other mental health concerns.
During psychoanalysis therapy, psychoanalysts and patients work collaboratively to identify and understand how past experiences affect present lives. During psychoanalysis treatment, the psychoanalysts allow patients to explore unconscious or repressed thoughts and feelings through talk. The unrestricted talking during psychoanalytic therapy enables the therapist to identify patterns of thinking and behavior of the person that contribute to the emotional distress.
According to the American Psychoanalytic Association, psychoanalytic therapy may require several weekly sessions to bring unconscious processes and defenses to the conscious mind so that the therapist can help examine the repressed thoughts and feelings of patients. A therapist can utilize psychoanalytic technique/s to help patients confront their repressed thoughts from childhood, heal from past experiences, and improve the symptoms of their mental health conditions.
Thanks for the feedback!
- Previous Article
- Next Article