Trauma Therapy Methods: Approaches To Mental Health And Traumatic Stress Treatment
Trauma usually involves a stressor, often called a traumatic event, that causes a person severe distress. A wide variety of events can lead to trauma. For example, natural disasters, car crashes, violence, abuse, war, homelessness, bullying, and chronic illness can all be traumatic experiences.
Acute trauma generally refers to the trauma-related symptoms a person experiences during and for a short time after a traumatic event. Chronic trauma typically refers to symptoms that last for weeks, months, or even years after the trauma took place. Complex trauma can describe the ongoing experience of traumatic events for an extended time or repeated traumatic events over time, as in cases of abuse.
Trauma Therapy Methods for Treating Mental Health and Traumatic Stress Disorder
All types of trauma can impact a person's mental health, potentially leading to mental health concerns like acute stress disorder (ASD), post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), panic attacks, or the resurfacing of traumatic memories. Trauma treatment often involves trauma therapy with mental health professionals, sometimes alongside prescription medications. In trauma-focused therapy, people usually focus specifically on how their past trauma affects their lives now and work to reduce symptoms stemming from trauma.
Trauma-informed therapy
Trauma-informed therapy can serve as an umbrella term describing any type of therapeutic approach that takes into consideration the profound impact of trauma on a person's mental health. Instead of simply trying to treat symptoms of trauma, trauma-informed therapy usually addresses how trauma has impacted a person's life. All of the other types of therapy listed in this article can be, and often are, conducted through a trauma-informed lens.
Six Principles of Trauma-Informed Care by SAMHSA
- Safety
- Trustworthiness and transparency
- Peer support
- Collaboration and mutuality
- Empowerment, voice, and choice
- Consideration of cultural, historical, and gender factors
Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT)
Randomized, controlled research studies have found that cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) can be used as a trauma-focused treatment and can treat PTSD, as well as reduce symptoms of anxiety and depression after trauma, in children, adolescents, and adults.
CBT for Trauma Recovery
In CBT sessions, people typically identify negative beliefs they hold about themselves and others, and then work to change any inaccurate beliefs. A person undergoing CBT for trauma may also explore and process emotions like self-blame, distrust of others, an exaggerated sense of danger, or a sense of inadequacy. They may identify negative coping strategies they've used to manage their trauma symptoms thus far, and then work to change those behaviors and engage in healthier coping strategies instead.
Cognitive processing therapy (CPT)
Studies show that cognitive processing therapy (CPT) can successfully treat PTSD. CPT is often specifically used to treat PTSD in people who have experienced trauma involving physical or sexual violence.
CPT is generally based on the idea that, after trauma, a person often develops distorted beliefs as they try to make sense of what happened. For example, they may analyze their behavior related to the trauma and blame themselves for being assaulted, when, in reality, they did not cause another person to commit assault. CPT can help a person work through these distorted beliefs and replace them with more accurate beliefs that can help them release negative feelings surrounding the trauma.
Exposure therapy and prolonged exposure therapy
In exposure therapy, a person may gradually receive more exposure to the situations they fear or avoid due to anxiety, despite those situations being safe. Through repeated exposure, the anxiety experienced in response to trauma-related stimuli tends to decrease. Initially, exposures may happen through imagining, writing about, or talking about a feared place, situation, thought, or feeling while in the safe space of a therapy session.
Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder Treatment Through Emotional Reprocessing
Prolonged exposure therapy is a type of exposure therapy that was created specifically to treat people with PTSD. In prolonged exposure therapy, a person may repeatedly revisit traumatic memories, and then process the experience through discussions with their therapist. This approach usually allows a person to reprocess their emotions surrounding trauma, and it is primarily based on the theory that people do not emotionally process traumatic events while they are happening.
In time, a person undergoing exposure therapy may begin gradually facing situations or places they avoid due to trauma by intentionally placing themselves in them in real life. This approach can help people reduce the anxiety they experience while out in the world and reduce the limitations they’ve put on their lives due to trauma.
Eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR) therapy
Eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR) is a unique therapy in which a person may think about traumatic memories as a therapist guides them through specific patterns of side-to-side eye movements. The purpose of EMDR is typically to help people identify and adopt more positive outlooks on their past trauma.
EMDR therapy normally treats PTSD through eight phases:
- Phase 1: The clinician takes a person's history.
- Phase 2: The clinician explains how EMDR works and prepares the client for the therapy.
- Phase 3: Together, the clinician and client assess the memory on which they are about to focus.
- Phases 4 to 7: The clinician and client work together to reprocess the memory so that it no longer causes as much distress. This usually involves making eye movements, identifying more positive thoughts about the traumatic events, and scanning the body for physical responses to the traumatic memory.
- Phase 8: The clinician and client evaluate the results of the treatment.
How Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing Fits into Trauma Therapy
Some people prefer EMDR therapy because it doesn't necessarily require them to talk or think about their thoughts and emotions surrounding trauma at length like some other therapies do. Instead, EMDR normally focuses on changing the body's reaction to specific memories and the way those memories are stored in the brain. By the end of EMDR therapy, traumatic memories should seem less vivid, and they should not be distressing to recall.
Internal family systems (IFS) therapy
Internal family systems (IFS) is another type of therapy that can reduce PTSD symptoms. IFS generally operates on the assumption that a person's self is made up of multiple parts. Some of these parts are considered "vulnerable" parts, and they may hold painful, traumatic memories. Others are "protective" parts, and they likely developed habits and ways of being that helped a person cope with or distract themselves from trauma at the time, but they may not be helpful in their current life.
How Self-Compassion Supports Mental Health After Traumatic Stress
In IFS, the mature, adult form of a person's self may try to act mindfully and with compassion as it "talks" with these vulnerable and protective parts. Developing this self-compassion may be particularly helpful for people who experienced trauma as children. When children experience trauma, they often develop self-blame, and self-compassion can change that line of thinking and replace it with something that is kinder and more accepting.
Remote therapy for trauma
Whether a person has PTSD or not, they may want to try therapy as a way of reprocessing traumatic memories and working through thoughts and emotions related to past trauma. Remote therapy could be an even more attractive option, since it typically allows a person to do the work of trauma reprocessing from the safety and comfort of home or another preferred location. BetterHelp is an online remote therapy platform that can pair you with a mental health professional who is equipped to help you.
Remote Trauma Therapy Methods: Benefits and Effectiveness
A scoping review of 38 research studies found that remotely delivered trauma therapy may treat trauma as well as in-person therapy while reducing stigma, reducing costs, and increasing access. However, the study authors caution that more research may be needed to explore potential risks, as well as other details related to remote therapy for trauma.
Trauma Therapy Methods for Veterans and Military Members
The studies that were reviewed looked at a variety of types of therapy given to veterans and military members, including prolonged exposure therapy, cognitive processing therapy, and cognitive behavioral therapy. While CBT appeared to return mixed results, all other forms of therapy reviewed were given a high rating for their ability to treat trauma.
Takeaway
What therapy is best for trauma?
The best trauma therapy depends on the individual’s needs. One approach may work for some but not for others. The effects of the traumatic event and what they went through are some of the factors to consider. One example of the best therapy for trauma is evidence-based trauma treatment, which can be a big help for those with posttraumatic stress disorder or complex trauma.
Other best therapy options include EMDR therapy, as it uses bilateral stimulation. It means that this kind of therapy involves the process of moving your eyes back and forth while recalling the memory. This one helps the brain to process traumatic memories in a more controlled way to reduce emotional distress. Another effective approach is dialectical behavior therapy. This approach helps manage intense emotions and feelings, especially for some individuals who experience multiple traumatic events.
Another trauma-focused treatment is trauma-informed therapy. This treatment ensures that an individual feels safe and supported in their healing process. Somatic experiencing is another one that addresses an individual how trauma can affect the nervous system regulation and ways to release tension. It is also common for a trauma-informed therapist to use trauma therapy techniques like experiential dynamic psychotherapy and accelerated experiential dynamic psychotherapy, which helps people understand their emotions and help them express them.
Therapies that mainly focus on distress tolerance and emotional regulation can be helpful for individuals who are trauma survivors of domestic violence or someone who is dealing with mental health issues. Talk therapy and behavioral techniques are often used together as therapeutic interventions, along with individual therapy. They are best for addressing trauma triggers.
A trauma-informed approach ensures that the therapy is safe and supportive for an individual, especially for their needs and treatment targets, as it can help promote a safe therapeutic environment for them to recover faster.
Why is EMDR so controversial?
Although EMDR is working really well, and many mental health professionals believe in its effectiveness in treating posttraumatic stress disorder, there are still some who question the mechanism and the exact flow of how it works, and that makes it controversial. The therapy process of EMDR involves recalling trauma-related memories and events while following specific eye movements. Others argue that this is not effective anymore, compared to traditional talk therapy. Although studies show that EMDR is giving a positive treatment outcome to the patients, many critics still believe that the exposure of the patients plays a big role rather than the eye movement themselves. Of course, many trauma survivors still believe and find EMDR helpful in helping them reduce stress responses. It also promotes the healing process in trauma-focused treatments.
Is EMDR or CBT better for trauma?
The best one depends on the individual’s choice and the assessment of a mental health professional since both EMDR and CBT are proven effective psychotherapy treatments for those individuals who experience trauma and trauma survivors. The main focus of EMDR is to process trauma-related memories using specific methods, which are trauma therapy techniques. However, CBT is more focused on the individual’s emotion regulation and helps them change their negative thought patterns. A trauma-informed therapist can recommend CBT to individuals with mental health disorders or personality disorders. At the same time, EMDR is for those individuals who are struggling with physical tension and trauma reminders. The final approach and trauma-informed therapy would still depend on your trauma-informed therapist and based on treatment targets and patients' trauma experiences.
What are the 5 R's of trauma?
The 5 R’s of trauma emphasize more on the important elements in trauma-informed therapy to help patients recover from their past or even a current traumatic event and experience. The 5 R’s guide trauma-informed treatment and emphasize future trauma-sensitive interventions in order to create a place that is safe and good for the patient’s healing.
Dr. Bruce Perry enumerated and described the 5 R’s as the following:
- Rhythmic- Activities with rhythm, such as dancing, drumming, and walking, help regulate the mind and body. It helps to reduce anxiety and stress and improves an individual’s emotions more stable. These activities are very helpful as they can support healing in trauma-related conditions.
- Repetitive- Consistently doing safe and positive things is very helpful in overcoming bad memories from past trauma. Doing things over and over again can help in the healing process, especially for those individuals with dissociative disorders and other mental health disorders.
- Rewarding- It helps people build more confidence by having enjoyable, fun, and positive experiences, as it can replace negative responses and feelings from past trauma-related situations. When they overcome even small challenges, they may feel a sense of happiness and become proud, which is very necessary and a big help during psychotherapy treatments.
- Relational- A therapeutic relationship or fostering trust between a patient and the therapist is an important part of the healing process. Individuals struggling with trauma triggers and trauma reminders would have difficulty opening up or staying connected if they feel that there is no sense of connection between them.
- Relevant- Various therapeutic methods must match an individual’s thinking and feelings based on the clinical practice guideline. Trauma therapy or treatment should be appropriate or right for their age and current situations to ensure effective healing from domestic violence or other trauma-related situations.
By integrating and using these therapeutic methods into trauma therapy, individuals can heal deeply and feel emotionally better for a long time,
What is the gold standard for trauma treatment?
Trauma-focused therapy is one of the gold standards for treating a traumatic event. This is a type of trauma-informed therapy, and this one is designed to help patients process their emotions and heal from their experiences, such as domestic violence. It focuses on having a strong therapeutic relationship between a patient and the therapist and creating a safe space for recovery through trauma-informed care. Effective treatment involves dealing with personality disorders and interpersonal effectiveness.
Who is EMDR not appropriate for?
EMDR is not appropriate or recommended for patients when treatment involves unmanaged psychosis, extreme emotional instability, and severe dissociation. It may worsen the condition of an individual instead of helping them.
Thanks for the feedback!
- Previous Article
- Next Article